Comments on: “Incarnate” by Nick Simmons

By: him

him — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 20:35:03 +0000

OH MY GODDDDDDDD!!!!!!!you ripped off one piece too,fuck you nick simmons.hmm interesting what money can do.really??? from the son of gene simmon ?!@#@##,what the hell is that this ,how come radical comic doesnt realise this??oh i forgot the daddy is……….,with money………how come the riview from comic bulletin is “the perfect balance of dark comedy and action.a definite must buy!”comic bulletin.did gene pay them too?there is no comedy and here is action,the rip off one.]

By: him

him — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 20:19:30 +0000

why is the investigation takes so long?just take one manga of bleach in the heuco mundo arc where kenpachi fight Nnoitra,ichigo transformation,nel scene with Nnoitra,etc. and compare it with one of this thing,to make it interesting ask a 5 yo to be the judge im sure he will say it look the same.to me the only original thing he comes with is his own character which are drawn badly (just look at the blood splatter)the guy with the blue shirt.and oh the CHEESY line makes me think about a 5 years old kid own manga drawn.

By: him

him — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 20:13:37 +0000

sory anon i already buy this thing.yes i agree its not a manga its a transmutation gone wrong whre he attempt the forbidden alchemy of manga forbidden to people with no talent.but he does have a talent in the wannabie field.just look at his band ,he is only famous because of the father

By: him

him — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 20:07:51 +0000

after reading incarnate volume 3 which i didnt even read to the end just scrolling,there is a yugioh influence,bleach of course and etc.i thnk he just got no talent ,he is not inspired he is ripping off.in volume 3 there is a scene like kenpachi vs the arrancar Nnoitra, then ichigo with the full hollow mode,orihime crying,ichigo fight yammy yhe no 0 espada(in this ncarnate when he rip the head off),the black chick in this incarnate background seems like nel fighting against Nnoitra where she is also more powerful than Nnoitra.personally i love-hate bleach but this incarnate sucks big time .lucky you didnt rip off naruto because that is no 1 popular manga followed by bleach and one piece.if you rip off naruto then a lot of people sure going to get mad at you,lucky the production is halted maybe there is more rip off in store.also in volume 1 there seem to be a similiraty with deidara from naruto with mouths on the hand and pride manga version of fullmetal alchemist where the guy is fully a black shodow entity with eyes on the body.

By: him

him — Fri, 26 Feb 2010 14:03:33 +0000

to those saying people doesnt get outrage about it last year is because last year it is still a fresh rip off.over time it get a little bit famous.for him saying he never heard about bleach is almost impossible,how did he know mangas?if he buys it from bookstore he mut have look at other manga too but if h didnt its okay,but im pretty sure that once he read the other mangas he must check the web for other great mangas or even when he draw his comic he must check the web for tips how to draw.but the most thing that i dont like the most is how he doesnt want to admit he never heard about bleach.i bet right now he is begging his father to paid the bookstore which he buy the manga bleach from to shut their mouth.i hope someone notice my post and post it to some place as well.ok,lastly,if nick simmons is telling the truth the logical explaination is that one night nick was just in his room then some light come from the above telling him this idea.

By: Eternal Vigilance » Blog Archive » Nick Simmons called out on plagiarism charges

Thu, 25 Feb 2010 19:01:03 +0000

[...] on. But my curiosity had been piqued. This morning, however, I woke up to find five comments on my original post from outraged members of the manga community accusing Simmons of plagiarism and calling him a [...]

By: admin

admin — Thu, 25 Feb 2010 18:42:03 +0000

Wow! I had no idea. I just heard about the comic through the show and decided to pass along the info to the public. Thank you for the heads up. Copying is NOT COOL!

By: admin

admin — Thu, 25 Feb 2010 18:41:12 +0000

This is interesting. The first I’ve heard of this. I’m surprised there wasn’t an outrage last year when the comic came out. I’d love to hear more about this copyright infringement issue.

By: Titan

Titan — Thu, 25 Feb 2010 14:49:02 +0000

copy cat….

By: Anon

Anon — Wed, 24 Feb 2010 23:13:10 +0000

DO NOT SUPPORT OR PURCHASE THIS COMIC. IT IS NOT REAL MANGA, NOR SHOULD IT EVER BE CONSIDERED AS SUCH. IT IS A COPY OF TITE KUBO’S JAPANESE MANGA BLEACH, AND HAS STOLEN COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL FROM REAL MANGA SUCH AS VAMPIRE HUNTER D, VAN HELLSING AND EVEN NANA!!! DO NOT BUY THIS MANGA UNLESS YOU’RE A THEIF LIKE HIM!